A new Star takes the spotlight.

[Bloodcount]

Starcraft II... things are going to be pretty much new to evryone... I am guessing that mapping will be popular only after 2-3 years though... not that there aren't going to maps... I am sure that "Days Of The Alliance" now with extra ice frogs for the first 23746 mad zombies(tm) will appear quite soon. Though it won't be good. Ok, why do I say 2-3 years? Well, my friends, 2 expansions, + custom gamers are melee players who got bored... So, yeah, mapping will be pretty pointless from start. Also I beleave that a new generation of maps will be needed. No fucking ORPG's Footman clones nor mindless AoS maps... I think that dispite our experiense with wc3 a kid with better ideas then us can own our... well pineapples :S

What do you think ?

 

[13lade619]

+ custom gamers are melee players who got bored

well... user-generated-content is what makes the gaming world evolve.

 

[FhelZone]

Lolz, I agree so much 13lade. When I got bored with the melee I just cheat it and arrange the buildings like sims, when I found out how to use WE I quit doing the sims in warcraft lolz.....

 

[xxxtrickyxxx]

i also agree with bloodcount that the mapping community isnt going to last as long with starcraft. although i am sure the editor will have alot of improvements and new stuff, the starcraft theme itself is going to be pretty limited. warcraft had that rpg element to it that made it much easier to make maps for, however starcraft from what i have seen sofar seems to be mostly about straight forward RTS melee fights. there are alot of possibilities with medieval and magic themes than the scifi space stuff. warcraft just simply had that IT factor making it possible to come up with endless map ideas that made sense to have in the warcraft universe. unless blizzard plans to have as many if not more different kinds of units and models as warcraft 3 in terms of normal units, campaign units, and neutral units etc, as well as just as many doodads and destructibles then I cant see starcraft mapping going very far. someone can only take so many mauls and maps with endless zerg waves.

im still going to get sc2 to check out the editor, but i honestly probably wont play it much.

 

[Ashcat]

Well, starcraft has those psionic powers, which come close to magical capabilities, and there are a lot of space age mmoRPGs. I disagree that sc2 maps will be more limited than wc3 maps. Maps come out of the creator's creativity and imagination, and the lore was only bent for about 5billion custom wc3 maps, so not every sc2 map will have to make perfect sense.

 

[Bloodcount]

well, listen starcraft II maps will be different. For example a map only with zerglings... the set of units races and theme SC gives us is limited, yes, but I beleave that the maps will be more minigame like...

 

[FhelZone]

I don't think so, I think its the start of epic maps. Considering that there are more unique systems in the new starcraft (Some units can walk on higher terrains @_@ - the spider like robots) Protoss takes the magic, zerg takes the alien, terran takes the human things. And I bet that the limit for the filesize will be much bigger than wc3's 4MB limit.

 

[Slapshot136]

hopefully we can export/import wc3 models if necessary or they will be there as a bonus (like the firebat/zergling/hydra in wc3)

 

[Tom Jones]

Starcraft II... things are going to be pretty much new to evryone... I am guessing that mapping will be popular only after 2-3 years though... not that there aren't going to maps... I am sure that "Days Of The Alliance" now with extra ice frogs for the first 23746 mad zombies(tm) will appear quite soon. Though it won't be good. Ok, why do I say 2-3 years? Well, my friends, 2 expansions, + custom gamers are melee players who got bored... So, yeah, mapping will be pretty pointless from start. Also I beleave that a new generation of maps will be needed. No fucking ORPG's Footman clones nor mindless AoS maps... I think that dispite our experiense with wc3 a kid with better ideas then us can own our... well pineapples :S

What do you think ?

Are you kidding? Within a week all SC custom maps will be cloned, and within a month they'll actually be playable. And not all custom gamers are melee gamers who got bored, for example I'm simply not fast enough to play melee, neither do I have the strategic overview, which is also the sole reason why I started modding back in the days.

 

[C-Death]

Starcraft II... things are going to be pretty much new to evryone... I am guessing that mapping will be popular only after 2-3 years though... not that there aren't going to maps... I am sure that "Days Of The Alliance" now with extra ice frogs for the first 23746 mad zombies(tm) will appear quite soon. Though it won't be good. Ok, why do I say 2-3 years? Well, my friends, 2 expansions, + custom gamers are melee players who got bored... So, yeah, mapping will be pretty pointless from start. Also I beleave that a new generation of maps will be needed. No fucking ORPG's Footman clones nor mindless AoS maps... I think that dispite our experiense with wc3 a kid with better ideas then us can own our... well pineapples :S

What do you think ?

Well put friend. I think that for a while, it's going to be 100% pointless.

 

[Frozenhelfir]

I disagree with the OP. There are a lot of custom gamers who do not play custom games because they got bored with melee maps. Warcraft III has a large base of custom gamers, and I know a lot of people who are making the jump to SC2 to play custom games.

That said, I would say custom games wont be played for a month or two until people finish the campaign and allow for the maps to develop to a playable level. When I got Wc3 i didn't play any ladder. I jumped right into the custom games.

 

[monoVertex]

hopefully we can export/import wc3 models if necessary or they will be there as a bonus (like the firebat/zergling/hydra in wc3)

You will not be able to import the old wc3 ones because of the game engine differences. But if anyone recreates them for sc2...

However, I think the only limit is the creator's imagination. And honest to be, we will be less limited than in wc3, think at all the things you will actually be able to do with the scripting in sc2 <3.

 

[Razalgrim]

Starcraft II doesn't have neutral creeps, right? If that's so, the custom maps are going to be very limited. You won't be able to make an RPG with only the units from 3 races to choose from.

 

[DarkRevenant]

Starcraft II doesn't have neutral creeps, right? If that's so, the custom maps are going to be very limited. You won't be able to make an RPG with only the units from 3 races to choose from.

I think it is your imagination and creativity that is limited.

 

[Razalgrim]

Even if you have enough imagination as to get drunk with it, if the resources are limited, the outcome can't be what initially conceptualized. Unless you limit your imagination to the confines of what's available to you.

Huh.

Ah well, I guess I'll just see myself once the game comes out.

 

[Razalgrim]

Fail double post. Sorry bout that, I'm on my bad laggy comp.

 

[Ioannes]

I agree with xxxtrickyxxx, there will be less applicable concepts in a SC2 custom map. The RPG element, for example, although do-able via triggers, will still lack items and so it will be, at best, incomplete.

Yet we should not worry. As tricky mentioned, the game will be more about straightforward RTS fighting, so there will be, consequentially, greater focus on the RTS elements in the new maps. For example, now, for the first time in a Blizz strategy (hallelujah!) I will be able to control MORE than 12 units. FhelZone is quite right, since the many new elements that will enhance the RTS experience will turn the mapmakers' creativity to implementing these elements in the new maps as well.

What I like about the pro RTS tilt in game design is that concepts such as the RingWars maps from TFT will be easy to implement in SC2 as opposed to TFT and the battles, assuming we get the needed models, will be much bigger and more LotR-like, and therefore more fun! I am already thinking of translating the RingWars concept into a non-LotR franchise, but I have not yet decided what

 

[Bloodcount]

>lack items
Actually heroes and items are included in the Star edit. there just aren't gonna be used in the classical game.

Indeed, the RTS element will be greater. But then comes the balancing problem...

 

[ButcherBunny]

Indeed, Bloodcount.

About the maps, I am sure that someone will re-make dota and the brainless dota players will play it like brainless zombies.

 

[C-Death]

Indeed, Bloodcount.

About the maps, I am sure that someone will re-make dota and the brainless dota players will play it like brainless zombies.

Wouldn't surprise me