Sci/Tech Mind Reading Is Now Possible

The Helper

Necromancy Power over 9000
Staff member
Reaction score
1,656
A computer can tell with 78 percent accuracy when someone is thinking about a hammer and not pliers.

Crime investigators always have their ears open for information only a perpetrator could know—where a gun used in a murder was stashed, perhaps, or what wounds a stabbing inflicted. So imagine a detective asking a suspect about a killing, describing the crime scene to get the suspect to visualize the attack. The detective is careful not to mention the murder weapon. Once the suspect has conjured up the scene, the detective asks him to envision the weapon. Pay dirt: his pattern of brain activity screams "hammer" as loud and clear as if he had blurted it out.

To detect patterns of brain activity, a subject must agree to lie still in a neuroimaging device such as a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) tube, but in an age when many jurisdictions compel not only convicts but also suspects to provide a DNA sample, that isn't difficult to imagine. Now, neither is the prospect of reading thoughts by decoding brain-activity patterns. Just a year ago, neuroscientists couldn't do much better than distinguish thoughts of faces from thoughts of places (the brain has distinct regions that process images of each). "All we could do was tell which brain region was active," says neuroscientist John-Dylan Haynes of the Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences in Leipzig, Germany. "There were real limits on our ability to read the content of that activity." No longer. "The new realization is that every thought is associated with a pattern of brain activity," says Haynes, "and you can train a computer to recognize the pattern associated with a particular thought."

 
Last edited:

Father_Yetti

New Member
Reaction score
45
That is really cool, though I doubt that we are near implementing this as viable evidence in a courtroom. Lie detectors are not even considered conclusive. I think that it couldn't hurt to try, and if it helps with the investigation producing actual supporting evidence - then it could prove extremely prudent. Of course getting one to agree to it; that would require either misinforming them, stupidity, or new contempt of court laws. I think it's heading in the right direction though I can still see some possibilities for abuse. But that territory goes with all new technologies. Either way I'm sure its full speed ahead, and who knows - probably for the better.
 

SilverHawk

General Iroh - Dragon of the West
Reaction score
88
That's awesome!

Though, I do agree with Father_Yetti that it will take some time to get it viable as evidence. But still, this is an amazing progress - hopefully more great things come from this.
 

Aqua Dragon

I'm made of water. Remember that now.
Reaction score
71
Agreed with you both. Not completely verifiable, but you have to start somewhere :D

However, I'm wondering if people are going to start saying that something like the first amendment would be forcing people a bit much. How? I'm pretty sure you can figure that out o_O
 

SilverHawk

General Iroh - Dragon of the West
Reaction score
88
The Fifth Amendment will probably come into play, I imagine - it's the one that protects you from testifying against yourself.
 

Jessi

I'm so green. Like a Machine.
Reaction score
37
Who cares if it is evidence in itself? The fact that you can describe the crime scene, then have them envision the weapon, and possible the location they hid it in, is phenominally helpful. This will help loads of innocent suspects, as well.
 

Father_Yetti

New Member
Reaction score
45
Who cares if it is evidence in itself? The fact that you can describe the crime scene, then have them envision the weapon, and possible the location they hid it in, is phenominally helpful. This will help loads of innocent suspects, as well.
I completely agree with you, but where I think this may run into a problem technically speaking is will it be legal to use?
 

King TonGoll

ORLY?*DDR*
Reaction score
87
I don't like this. we can't keep going down this path! this scares me lol. We cant let ourselfs throw away our freedoms for safety!

my freedom of thought, and privacy of thoughts might be invaded, i don't know about you, but i don't like this one bit, the thought that china can handle its thought police better is even worse. do you not think that this could be used for such reasons? it is the only thing it serves for, invading a mans land of privacy.
 

H34DhUnT3r

Ultra Cool Member
Reaction score
35
I don't like this. we can't keep going down this path! this scares me lol. We cant let ourselfs throw away our freedoms for safety!

my freedom of thought, and privacy of thoughts might be invaded, i don't know about you, but i don't like this one bit, the thought that china can handle its thought police better is even worse. do you not think that this could be used for such reasons? it is the only thing it serves for, invading a mans land of privacy.
hmmm what are you hiding? :p
 

Asehujiko

New Member
Reaction score
20
So if i force myself to think of a teaspoon i'm partialy immune to it?

What will happen if you hook this up to a paranormal? Will we see TS: FS like scenes where a supercomputer augment by a few psysic brains goes weird?
 

esb

Because none of us are as cruel as all of us.
Reaction score
327
Well, this, like everything else, has it's pros and cons. A few pros like Jessi said, and cons, well for the criminals. But sometimes, if you're hiding something emberassing, it would suck.

Anyway, I doubt this thing will be easy to get (to the point every police officer has one, or you can buy one from the market)
 

Jessi

I'm so green. Like a Machine.
Reaction score
37
So if i force myself to think of a teaspoon i'm partialy immune to it?

What will happen if you hook this up to a paranormal? Will we see TS: FS like scenes where a supercomputer augment by a few psysic brains goes weird?
No. Not at all. It's not concious thought it's reading, it's reading the fleeting thoughts that your mind conjures up as it makes connections between what the police officer is saying to you, and what is happening. Theoretically, they could have the suspect replaying the entire crime in their mind with the suspect not even realizing it.
 

Ninva

Анна Ахматова
Reaction score
378
It's sad. Soon the machines will take our positions as working men, and our government will become a communist, and we'll live materialistically. :(
This is great news to innocent suspects, but to the honest men who work these jobs it may not be... but who's really honest in this line of duty? They're cut throats just as much as the men they're trying to punish. Maybe we need more machines taking the stands and sentencing harsh law upon our American people.
 

Darkchaoself

What is this i dont even
Reaction score
106
These cannot be implemented for A LONG time. Even in years when they can read minds to find exact things, it can't be used unless its 100% accurate 100% of the time.
 

Lobster

Old Fogey ofthe site
Reaction score
92
I can't read minds, but I can tell the future, heres a prediction:

I predict that someday someone will say the word "hello"
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.

    The Helper Discord

    Members online

    No members online now.

    Affiliates

    Hive Workshop NUON Dome World Editor Tutorials

    Network Sponsors

    Apex Steel Pipe - Buys and sells Steel Pipe.
    Top