Reversing a singly linked list

jonas

Ultra Cool Member
Code:
rec_reverse(last_of_rev,to_rev) = if to_rev != nil:
  next_rev = to_rev.next;
  to_rev.next = last_of_rev;
  rec_reverse(to_rev,next_rev)

reverse(to_rev) = rec_reverse(nil, to_rev)
Code:
reversed list    list to be reversed
(|<-()<-...<-()  ,  []->()->...->()->|)
after one recurisve step becomes:
(|<-()<-...<-()<-[]  ,  ()->...->()->|)
at the end of recursion becomes:
(|<-()<-...<-()<-[]<-()<-...<-()  ,  |)
 
Last edited:

Accname

2D-Graphics enthusiast
How about this?
Code:
    public void reverse() {
       Node prev = null;
       Node current = first;
       while (current != null) {
         Node next = current.next;
         current.next = prev;
         prev = current;
         current = next;
       }
       first = prev;
     }
This is using a simple while-loop.
Here a full example with test case:
Code:
  public static void main(final String[] args) {
     LList l = new LList();
     l.first = new Node("A");
     l.first.next = new Node("B");
     l.first.next.next = new Node("C");
     l.first.next.next.next = new Node("D");
     l.first.next.next.next.next = new Node("E");
     l.first.next.next.next.next.next = new Node("F");
    
     System.out.println(l);
     System.out.println();
     l.reverse();
     System.out.println(l);
     System.out.println();
   }
  
   public static class LList {
     Node first;
    
     public void reverse() {
       Node prev = null;
       Node current = first;
       while (current != null) {
         Node next = current.next;
         current.next = prev;
         prev = current;
         current = next;
       }
       first = prev;
     }
    
     @Override
     public String toString() {
       StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder();
       Node current = first;
       while (current != null) {
         sb.append(current.value);
         sb.append(" ");
         current = current.next;
       }
       return sb.toString();
     }
   }
  
   static class Node {
     Object value;
     Node next;
    
     public Node(Object value) {
       this.value = value;
     }
    
   }
Output:
A B C D E F

F E D C B A
 

Accname

2D-Graphics enthusiast
Its not quite the same depending on the execution enviroment and language you are using. A loop is much better in java than recursion. Sure, at some point the JIT will jump in and might improve the recursive method, but until then the loop will outperform the recursion every time.
 

jonas

Ultra Cool Member
Its not quite the same depending on the execution enviroment and language you are using. A loop is much better in java than recursion. Sure, at some point the JIT will jump in and might improve the recursive method, but until then the loop will outperform the recursion every time.
Note that I was not giving a java program... At the conceptual level the two are identical, and that was the level in which I was giving the algorithm. Yes, in a given actual implementation the performance between the two may differ significantly, and one of them may run out of memory while the other may not (this is actually the bigger issue). From my point of view, you have simply given the idiomatic Java implementation of the conceptual algorithm above. Maybe we can find common ground here?
 

Accname

2D-Graphics enthusiast
You have to go to a veeeeerrrryyy high conceptual level to call these two implementations equal. Sure, in the end they do the same thing because thats what they are supposed to do. But both use different syntactic and semantic constructs some of which may or may not be available in a given language / runtime enviroment.
 

jonas

Ultra Cool Member
You have to go to a veeeeerrrryyy high conceptual level to call these two implementations equal. Sure, in the end they do the same thing because thats what they are supposed to do. But both use different syntactic and semantic constructs some of which may or may not be available in a given language / runtime enviroment.
The first one is not an implementation, it's a description of the algorithm. There might not even be a compiler or interpreter for that language.
I wouldn't just say that they do the same thing, I'd go as far to say they do it the *same way*, namely by going through the pointers and flipping them one by one. Recursion and iteration just say "repeatedly do this", or "repeatedly do this until".
 

Accname

2D-Graphics enthusiast
Thats a little to vague for my taste. A loop is an actual syntactical structure defined by a language. Recursion is a method of software-developement that can be used in most languages but there is no syntactical component to it in any language I know of. There are many different languages, some of which do not have loops. Some of them do not have the concept of methods either but they have loops. Some have methods but do not allow for recursion, etc.
I can not say with a straight face that these two things are "the same". They might be very similar, they might be exchangeable in most enviroments, but they are not "the same".
 

jonas

Ultra Cool Member
Well, I understand that you live in the practical world of building real software, where there are very clearly specific definitions and precise differences for these definitions. If I would develop a Java program, I would use a while loop, not a recursive method call, just like you have.

I on the other hand live in the theoretical world of building language models and proving that can be compiled correctly to run on real machines, so I'm looking more at the conceptual level of what languages can do (in general) and how it would be compiled and run, and so in my world they use the same mechanisms and I don't distinguish between them. Whether a language implements "doing the same thing over and over" by function recursion or loop recursion or a recursion operator (like system T) is completely irrelevant to me; if it has a way of "doing the same thing over and over", it needs to do a) b) and c) to compile correctly for x86.
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
  • The Helper The Helper:
    It is possible to automate it so that instead of moving to Archive if it has the Science, technology or sci tech tag that it gets archived there instead. I am considering a new Weird News Tag
  • tom_mai78101 tom_mai78101:
    Please do. I'll try to tag the news appropriately when I get the chance.
  • The Helper The Helper:
    The new Discourse forum software we are moving to next does alot with the tags and also hashtags
  • The Helper The Helper:
    OK I found the source of your burrito post stuff it is from Reddit and possibly a facebook post too but definitely reddit
  • The Helper The Helper:
    Happy Monday!
  • The Helper The Helper:
    Happy Tuesday :)
  • Blackveiled Blackveiled:
    Happy Tuesday
  • The Helper The Helper:
    Blackveiled! What is up?
  • The Helper The Helper:
    I saw XXXConan on here the other day I dont know if you remember him
  • The Helper The Helper:
    blasts from the past
  • Blackveiled Blackveiled:
    I remember him, buncha old faces
  • jonas jonas:
    He's a software engineer at a hiring platform now I think
  • The Helper The Helper:
    I wanna know if his mom is still single LOL
  • tom_mai78101 tom_mai78101:
    I need context.
    +1
  • The Helper The Helper:
    Back in the day conan was a young one and his mom was single and I used to tease him that I was going to date his mom and be his daddy - yeah sounds bad now but it was funny at the time
  • The Helper The Helper:
    his mom is my age
  • The Helper The Helper:
    i know right it was pretty funny
  • thewrongvine thewrongvine:
    its pretty funny
    +1
  • tom_mai78101 tom_mai78101:
    Thanks for the context.
    +1
  • The Helper The Helper:
    Happy Hump Day!!!
  • Blackveiled Blackveiled:
    TH old fart gotta have a beer with me one of these days
  • The Helper The Helper:
    I am down anytime Blackveiled
  • Blackveiled Blackveiled:
    count on it then cause you don't live that far from me hah
  • The Helper The Helper:
    really that is cool! I am in Houston in the 77079 area

    Staff online

    Members online

    Affiliates

    Hive Workshop NUON Dome World Editor Tutorials

    Network Sponsors

    Apex Steel Pipe - Buys and sells Steel Pipe.
    Top