TD Terrain - Comments required!

[SD_Ryoko]

I am undecided and really not happy with the way my terrain looks.

What do you think is better. The black, the brown, or the original dalaran?

The black costs me 160kb and looks horrible against the trim grass, but hot everywhere else. I like it. Except for that.

The brown or the purple save me good space. But the purple is old and brown isn't very exciting.

NONE of the other cliff tiles really give me what I want.

I can also change the black to a stone gray or something too.

 

[SD_Ryoko]

Barrens doodads on the left, or sunken ruins on the right? Do tell!

 

[Spastic]

I spent a few hours yesterday night trying to find a different icon and buff icon for the heal, abolish magic, and inner fire abilities, only to find out after finishing that the original ones made by Blizzard still looked a billion and a half times better than the ones I had labored so hard on.

My point is, Blizzard's Dalaran looks fantastic, even if it is a bit boring and uninspired.

 

[XXXconanXXX]

I like the black and Sunken Ruins. The pink looks ugly and boring but the black has a little bit more life. And the Sunken Ruins gives it that more "foresty" feel while Barrens gives it a desertish feel to it. If you want to save more space then go with the brown but never ever go with the pink it is down right ugly.

 

[Mind]

The quality of the Sunken Ruins tileset, in my humble opinion, greatly exceeds the quality of the older Barren tileset.

The brown tile perhaps looks rather ugly, but the purple tile looks abominable in my insight. The black tile, however, looks a lot better.

At the other hand, it's important that the map's size is not unnecessarily too large. I'd replace the black tile by the brown tile.

 

[vito]

black one is the best....Barrens doodads are better

 

[Mind]

The Barren Doodads are not suitable with the Sunken Ruins tiles.

The Sunken Ruins tileset also has a more extensive list of doodads, and its doodads are certainly of higher quality.

Finally, the Barren Doodads instigate the sphere of a barren, dry, empty, abandoned and forsaken place.