Cinematic Contest - Voting Thread

[mastah_]

I saw his vote in the poll. I think that his post explaining why just got removed by Tinki3. Good luck to all participants

huh?

oh you mean kazuga? didn't see his vote there

 

[Kazuga]

huh?

oh you mean kazuga? didn't see his vote there

Hm?
Anyway, It's a little funny Mastah, that you said in the beginning that you would probobly not win but you joined the contest for fun. Seems to me that you win big time gl.

Also an edit to why I think Mastahs is the best one:
It's real funny, it has good sense of humour, you get surprised even though you know what's going to happen, you can decide for yourself what will happen and it is very well made.
Also, blackrocks cinematic comes right after Mastahs for me, it's not as funny as mastahs but it's really well made and I was allmost stunnd after watching it.
Good luck all!

 

[ayumilove]

This two cinematics below can't be viewed on my warcraft application,
the rest are working <3

Exide_Battle of the Mountain - Cinematic Contest - Exide.w3x
Knight7770_Cinematic Contest ~ Dalaran Ruins Invasion v3.w3x

 

[Joker(Div)]

Comments

Spoiler

@Mastah_
   - A bit of humor
   - Decent length
   - Some Animation

@Knight7770
   - A bit lengthy
   - Has a storyline
   - Added some interacting

@Kazuga 
   - Way too lengthly
   - Too much annoying dialog
   - No effects (ending wasn't really part of cenamatic)

@Exide 
   - Not using cenamatic text?
   - Heavy Emphasis on animation
   - Nice terrain

@Black rock
   - Best animation out of rest
   - No dialog?
   - awesome fight scene

@Bronxernijn
   - Nice terrain
   - Best storyline (although a bit corny)
   - Little animation

Thoughts

Spoiler

@Mastah_
   That humor was meh, nothing else excited me about your cenamatic

@Knight7770
   Well you had a OK stoyline, but there was too much dialog.  The animation    didnt make up for it
 either.

@Kazuga
   ...No comment

@Exide
    Any reason not to use cenamatic dialog?  You got some cool animations in your fight scene and you
 have an awesome terrain.  Too bad the person under you topped everything in your cenamatic, meh.

@Black rock
   Awesome fight scene/terrain, although to make this even better, you could have added in some kind of
 a background story, but this one gets my vote.

@Bronxernijn
   You had a nice storyline, but there was nothing that caught my attention.

If I were to rank:

1st. Black rock
2nd Tied. Exide/Bronxernijn

Rants at Uberplayer

Spoiler

WTFOMFGBBQOSIDGNIOKSMVKDLSMKDCNOIDG
Why did you not submit this? You could have ended your cenamatic after the treant got frozen and sumbit part to later. Your cenamatic's score would be higher than all these combined!

 

[ayumilove]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1yoL4b9zZZA
[YOUTUBE]1yoL4b9zZZA[/YOUTUBE]

 

[StrawyBlood]

Hehe
I love Cinamatic xDD
soo funny xD
My vote is for Mastah_
I love when the orc destroy the cameras xDD

 

[ayumilove]

part2 cinematics
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJUKbgAPDvE
[YOUTUBE]AJUKbgAPDvE[/YOUTUBE]

 

[Battlemapsta]

I chose Mastah's for its slight humor and uniqueness to pull you into watching it. The other cinematics were good in terraining and storylines which are my most favorite aspects but the camera work and action lacked far too much to obtain my vote.

Dota one came very close but a bit of some fast camera spicing could've grabbed my vote.

To Ayumilove: Ooo nice thing you did there for people having difficulty viewing this. I think doing this for the contest was very sincere. +rep

 

[Kazuga]

aymilove, gj with editing the videos on youtube .

 

[PurgeandFire]

I liked BlackRock's, best use of cinematography in my opinion out of this batch.

Good job all.

 

[NuBy]

Sorry to ask this, but I still don't get the joke in Mastah_'s cinematic. May anyone explain please? Or was the one in Ayumilove's video the actual cinematic. The one I watch on the map section was completely different.

*EDIT* Woops, I downloaded the older version of the cinematic... The scene from the Holy Grail was quite funny lol, you put quite a lot of work into that Mastah_!

 

[Battlemapsta]

Hehe tight race. Mastah ahead by one. Common people drop your vote in

 

[vypur85]

Voted for Black Rock's. Have same reason with Post#14 (Gals). But the video made me dizzy at some point. And it's not DotA at all .

 

[Knight7770]

Looks like it's between Mastah_ and Black Rock now

 

[Tinki3]

Results are in, take a look at the first post.

 

[Knight7770]

Awesome! Congratulations, Black Rock
What's the prize?

 

[Tinki3]

> What's the prize?

At the moment, it's just +rep from me and whoever else wants to.

 

[Knight7770]

Cool. I've already +repped the winner
Who wants to +rep the 3rd place winners?

 

[Black rock]

ahh...
thanks to all
but , my cinematic is not good at all.
I think other cinematic like The Unforgotten Grudge is better than my cinematic.

Spoiler

I'm work at other project right now , but I will try to visit this site often as I can

 

[Bronxernijn]

Woah, I had the highest judge score.

My very first map

Yes the ending was dull, a time issue indeed. Im in the final period of my secondary school. I saw the contest here so I decided it would be good to learn triggering.

The end was more going to be an epic battle, but because of time issues, I could not do this, and I could not use the entire map (like the farm, which I really liked). I am glad to hear the terrain looks good. I never did terraining before.

So Tinki3, thanks for the positive judgement Im really continuing mapmaking now.

EDIT: Everyone thanks for the +rep. It just pentalooped