BANANAMAN
Resident Star Battle Expert.
- Reaction score
- 150
Football is mainly just about getting the ball to the goal and the various means you would do it.True you have to think about strategies on how to get the ball to the goal along with thinking of counters to the opponents counter's to your strategies but it's just really limited on where you move your guys and where you shoot and pass the ball.Now to a more individual perspective you have to just make sure the ball makes it to the goal which would depend on whether or not you want to coordinate and work with your teammates.Strategies and tactics are planned in football and like any other sports where you can see the entire field of play which is based on the information you can glean from the field of play.
In Starcraft however this changes and as one Teamliquid poster so aptly put it.
also if anything a 6v6 would in theory as Nighshade would point out would require more intellect. Provided every team is filled with competent players that don't spam one unit.
Baby had been training since middle school so does that count?
Firstly how can you even compare the different positions in football to having 3 starcraft races? It's not even the same thing.Tactics and positioning in football is basically much the same in every game.Starcraft however has varying fields of play that have varying terrain features and base start locations so you can't really think about how to position your units until the game starts even if there's a minimap since you might find out that the perfect spot to place your seige tanks for example is already occupied by a giant chunk of undestroyable debris.True some people try and study all the maps in circulation or at least the maps involved in the tournament he or she is participating in but it's more on them getting a feel of the map trying to take note and memorize all possible routes,etc so that they can formulate a decent opening against their opponent.
Those are present in Starcraft.In fact if you speed football up 2x add in how the team manages to obtain money without sponsorships to buy new equipment and maintain it,the coaches pitted against each other 1v1 thinking and coping of ways how they manage their players and keep them in line along with actually thinking up a strategy to win the game then you pretty much have 1vs1 match in starcraft with the coaches as the players and the football players as the units.
In Starcraft however this changes and as one Teamliquid poster so aptly put it.
DefMatrixUltra from TeamLiquid.net: said:Game 1
Game 2
Game 3
Game 1 demonstrates the importance of scouting - something that chess does not have. Chess is a game of perfect information, Starcraft is a game of limited information. July uses Best's limited information to surprise him with a 5-pool. This game has nothing to do with clicking. You can also talk about the psychological disadvantage this puts Best in - his opponent just did something ridiculous in the most prestigious tournament in Starcraft and won.
Game 2 demonstrates the importance of seizing an opportunity - something that chess does not have. Since chess is not played in real-time (that is, since you cannot macro or micro in chess to improve your game), players act based on knowledge of all current and future possibilities. However, Starcraft is too 'big' a game to even look a few steps ahead. When July sees the small unit count in Best's base and realizes his overlord is going to die, he makes another incredible gamble (he could potentially have lost the game immediately) and does that awesome Bisu-face drone drill. In effect, he is changing the rules of the game. Best had access to his base blocked. Nothing could get past. Except July decided to do something unexpected and unprecedented.
Game 3 is so full of strategy and psychology that I'll let you fill in the blanks.
also if anything a 6v6 would in theory as Nighshade would point out would require more intellect. Provided every team is filled with competent players that don't spam one unit.
Baby had been training since middle school so does that count?
then we come to the actual gameplay, where, hey! look! the plan isnt working so instead i sha'll pass the ball to this guy! or, everybody is covered, so i shall take a run! then you have the tactics of trying to wear your opponents down, mentally and physically, before you take some real chances, or maybe try hard right away, score a goal, and destroy their morale completely! We could try playing organized and maybe that will work, or maybe we could try to be risky and take our chances, or maybe try our individual skills.
and then we come to the point were there are a LOT of different positions, which you could relate to having 3 starcraft races.
Firstly how can you even compare the different positions in football to having 3 starcraft races? It's not even the same thing.Tactics and positioning in football is basically much the same in every game.Starcraft however has varying fields of play that have varying terrain features and base start locations so you can't really think about how to position your units until the game starts even if there's a minimap since you might find out that the perfect spot to place your seige tanks for example is already occupied by a giant chunk of undestroyable debris.True some people try and study all the maps in circulation or at least the maps involved in the tournament he or she is participating in but it's more on them getting a feel of the map trying to take note and memorize all possible routes,etc so that they can formulate a decent opening against their opponent.
look! the plan isnt working so instead i sha'll pass the ball to this guy! or, everybody is covered, so i shall take a run! then you have the tactics of trying to wear your opponents down, mentally and physically, before you take some real chances, or maybe try hard right away, score a goal, and destroy their morale completely!
Those are present in Starcraft.In fact if you speed football up 2x add in how the team manages to obtain money without sponsorships to buy new equipment and maintain it,the coaches pitted against each other 1v1 thinking and coping of ways how they manage their players and keep them in line along with actually thinking up a strategy to win the game then you pretty much have 1vs1 match in starcraft with the coaches as the players and the football players as the units.