Iconpack Acid Shield & Ice Shard

[Trollvottel]

Well, I tried to edit a few icons and thats the result:

Acid Shield

Ice Shards

I hope I'll get better but I am content with it

Icon borders by Cohadars Borderizer (BTN, DISBTN, PASBTN and AUTOCAST.)

No credits needed if you use one of them.

 

[duyen]

First 1 looks like a recolor with some shading but second one is nice

 

[Quauhtli]

Personally give following remarks:
Acid Shield.
6.75/10
It's pretty nicely recolored, but just next time put more effort into things when you are recoloring them. The shading is nice though.
Ice Shards.
7.25/10
This one is a little better, although in my opinion I can't really see any ice in there. Perhaps some recolored crystals flying down from space or something. Add a more sky feeling to the background and make them more white / teal to have them be more icy.

Oh and by the way you should make a DISPASBTN if you make PASBTN, and a AUTOCAST turn off.

 

[Drunken_God]

why you think he recolored everything?
i think they are cool

 

[Trollvottel]

Well it IS recolored
thx for your comments

~update
made a second ice shard version

 

[ragingspeedhorn]

To be honest I don't like the recolor or the first iceshards icon at all, especially not the recolor, it's too blurry and the color theme doesn't work very well.

The second iceshards icon though, that one looks good, it has gotten that much needed finishing touch that the first one lacks. I would submit this one as a standalone resource, or perhaps with a improved iceshards 1 icon and completely ditch the poor recolor.

 

[Tom Jones]

To be honest I don't like the recolor or the first iceshards icon at all, especially not the recolor, it's too blurry and the color theme doesn't work very well.

The second iceshards icon though, that one looks good, it has gotten that much needed finishing touch that the first one lacks. I would submit this one as a standalone resource, or perhaps with a improved iceshards 1 icon and completely ditch the poor recolor.

I completely agree, Iceshard2 approved and can be found here:
Iceshard2 thread

This thread and the approved thread has been edited accordingly.