Buying speakers, I want YOUR advice!

Fragglez

New Member
Reaction score
4
I'm buying speakers to serve my music and gaming!

Now heres the thing, we all have to learn sometime, and I need to know what to look out for. I know this much:

high wattage = the louder sound can go without being distorted
You want somewhat of a balance with wattage with the bass and satellites, bass being the dominant one.

And I know some basics on "rms" and "PMPO" thanks to wikipedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audio_power (or listed below)

RMS
A meaningful and reliable measure of the maximum power output of an audio amplifier, or the power handling of a loudspeaker is continuous sine wave power, or more strictly continuous average sine wave power. Harmonic distortion increases with power output; the maximum continuous power output of an amplifier is always stated at a given percentage of distortion, say 1% THD+N at 1 kHz. Considerably more power can be delivered if distortion is allowed to increase; some manufacturers quote maximum power at a higher distortion, like 10%, making their equipment appear more powerful than if measured at an acceptable distortion level. Continuous power is often referred to as "[true] RMS power", although this is technically incorrect: while RMS (Root Mean Square) power is a valid quantity, it is neither useful as a measurement nor what is intended by those who use the term. The sine wave power is found by averaging the instantaneous power output over either a long period of time ('continuous or RMS power') or one complete cycle ('music power'), so it is actually the average power or mean power. For a resistive load such as most loudspeakers the average power is the product of the RMS current and RMS voltage.

In common use RMS, when applied to power measurements, has come to mean "sine-wave power." A 100 Watt "RMS" amplifier can produce a 100 Watt sine-wave into its load. With music, the total actual power would be less. With a square-wave, it would be more.
PMPO (none of the speakers listed below are PMPO)
a much more dubious measure, of interest more to advertising copy-writers than to consumers. The term PMPO has never been defined in any standard but it is often taken to be the sum of some sort of peak power for each amplifier in a system. Different manufacturers use different definitions, so that the ratio of PMPO to continuous power output varies widely; it is not possible to convert from one to the other. Peak power is twice the sine wave power, so, for example, a 5 channel system using amplifiers which can output 10 watts for a few milliseconds with an unspecified percentage of distortion would be specified as '100 watts PMPO'. Sometimes, an extra factor is applied to get an even higher figure. The term PMPO is considered misleading and meaningless by audio professionals. Most amplifiers can sustain their PMPO for only a very short time; loudspeakers are not designed to withstand their stated PMPO for anything but a momentary peak without serious damage. Sometimes the PMPO which can be delivered into an unrealistic resistive load, rather than a real loudspeaker, is quoted. There have been genuine attempts to measure 'peak music power' as described below, but in general the term is not at all useful.[citation needed]

The true power output of an amplifier can be estimated by examining the input current. Linear amplifiers tend to be about 60% efficient at best. A switch-mode amplifier (known as class D) can achieve much higher efficiency, sometimes as high as 95%. A linear car amplifier labeled "500 W PMPO" but fitted with a 5-amp fuse can, at most, deliver an average power of 5 A × 14.4 V × 60%, or about 43 watts. (100% efficiency is always used for PMPO)

Peak momentary power output and peak music power output are two different measurements with different specification and should not be used interchangeably. Every time a manufacturer uses different words such as pulse or performance they do so to reflect some non standard system of measurement of their own, where only they know what it means. The Federal Trade Commission is putting an end to this Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Rule, Power Output Claims for Amplifiers Utilized in Home Entertainment Products, 46 CFR 432 (1974).
Peak Momentary Power Output is the capacity to pass a single peak or a short train of peaks usually less than ten contiguous wave cycles. Peak Music Power Output requires the amplifier to pass up to 10 ms of the waveform or vastly longer pulse trains. Neither spec is standardized for music and neither required the amp to be able to handle the power for any continuous duty cycle. It's like buying grape juice, if the words grape and juice do not follow each other, it is probably not grape juice. These terms have had real meaning long before the audio industry began using them and are not at all misleading. RADAR amplifiers only care about peak momentary impulse power and CW Linear amplifiers only care about RMS because a continuous sine wave is all they do.

Now that this is stated, I would like to bring in these 2 products I have found that might be what I'm looking for!

Logitech THX Z-5300e 280 Watts RMS 5.1 Speaker
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16836121121
I see this and first notice that the watts on this are WAY higher!

Logitech G51 155 watts RMS 5.1 Surround Sound Speakers - Retail
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16836121012
I see this and notice some "matrix" on the controller, this seems nice and like a great thing to have.

This throws me off though, Why are ones with higher wattage at a lower price and with better reviews? What one is a better pick?

The question: What should I buy? Or if you have a different pick, feel free to show me!
Also, When does it get to the point when it is too much with watts?


Rep will be rewarded for even doing something as simple as posting here!

Thanks :)

Edit: Just in case it matters, my soundcard is the Creative Soundblaster X-fi Extreme Gamer.
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
  • Ghan Ghan:
    Still lurking
    +3
  • The Helper The Helper:
    I am great and it is fantastic to see you my friend!
    +1
  • The Helper The Helper:
    If you are new to the site please check out the Recipe and Food Forum https://www.thehelper.net/forums/recipes-and-food.220/
  • Monovertex Monovertex:
    How come you're so into recipes lately? Never saw this much interest in this topic in the old days of TH.net
  • Monovertex Monovertex:
    Hmm, how do I change my signature?
  • tom_mai78101 tom_mai78101:
    Signatures can be edit in your account profile. As for the old stuffs, I'm thinking it's because Blizzard is now under Microsoft, and because of Microsoft Xbox going the way it is, it's dreadful.
  • The Helper The Helper:
    I am not big on the recipes I am just promoting them - I use the site as a practice place promoting stuff
    +2
  • Monovertex Monovertex:
    @tom_mai78101 I must be blind. If I go on my profile I don't see any area to edit the signature; If I go to account details (settings) I don't see any signature area either.
  • The Helper The Helper:
    You can get there if you click the bell icon (alerts) and choose preferences from the bottom, signature will be in the menu on the left there https://www.thehelper.net/account/preferences
  • The Helper The Helper:
    I think I need to split the Sci/Tech news forum into 2 one for Science and one for Tech but I am hating all the moving of posts I would have to do
  • The Helper The Helper:
    What is up Old Mountain Shadow?
  • The Helper The Helper:
    Happy Thursday!
    +1
  • Varine Varine:
    Crazy how much 3d printing has come in the last few years. Sad that it's not as easily modifiable though
  • Varine Varine:
    I bought an Ender 3 during the pandemic and tinkered with it all the time. Just bought a Sovol, not as easy. I'm trying to make it use a different nozzle because I have a fuck ton of Volcanos, and they use what is basically a modified volcano that is just a smidge longer, and almost every part on this thing needs to be redone to make it work
  • Varine Varine:
    Luckily I have a 3d printer for that, I guess. But it's ridiculous. The regular volcanos are 21mm, these Sovol versions are about 23.5mm
  • Varine Varine:
    So, 2.5mm longer. But the thing that measures the bed is about 1.5mm above the nozzle, so if I swap it with a volcano then I'm 1mm behind it. So cool, new bracket to swap that, but THEN the fan shroud to direct air at the part is ALSO going to be .5mm to low, and so I need to redo that, but by doing that it is a little bit off where it should be blowing and it's throwing it at the heating block instead of the part, and fuck man
  • Varine Varine:
    I didn't realize they designed this entire thing to NOT be modded. I would have just got a fucking Bambu if I knew that, the whole point was I could fuck with this. And no one else makes shit for Sovol so I have to go through them, and they have... interesting pricing models. So I have a new extruder altogether that I'm taking apart and going to just design a whole new one to use my nozzles. Dumb design.
  • Varine Varine:
    Can't just buy a new heatblock, you need to get a whole hotend - so block, heater cartridge, thermistor, heatbreak, and nozzle. And they put this fucking paste in there so I can't take the thermistor or cartridge out with any ease, that's 30 dollars. Or you can get the whole extrudor with the direct driver AND that heatblock for like 50, but you still can't get any of it to come apart
  • Varine Varine:
    Partsbuilt has individual parts I found but they're expensive. I think I can get bits swapped around and make this work with generic shit though
  • Ghan Ghan:
    Heard Houston got hit pretty bad by storms last night. Hope all is well with TH.
  • The Helper The Helper:
    Power back on finally - all is good here no damage
    +2
  • V-SNES V-SNES:
    Happy Friday!
    +1
  • The Helper The Helper:
    New recipe is another summer dessert Berry and Peach Cheesecake - https://www.thehelper.net/threads/recipe-berry-and-peach-cheesecake.194169/

      The Helper Discord

      Members online

      No members online now.

      Affiliates

      Hive Workshop NUON Dome World Editor Tutorials

      Network Sponsors

      Apex Steel Pipe - Buys and sells Steel Pipe.
      Top