Iconpack Elements of Magic: The Gathering

[Ninja_sheep]

An item pack containing 5 icons based on the elements of the trading card game Magic: The Gathering
The pack contains: BTN, DISBTN, PASBTN, DISPASBTN and autocast button (no disabled autocast button).

These are the first icons i submit here so please don't kill me xD

enjoy!

 

[konerboy]

do you have photoshop?? if so i could give you some advice XD

 

[ragingspeedhorn]

Did you even make these yourself or did you just CnP these into Warcraft borders?

 

[Hatebreeder]

It's obvious that he copied and Pasted

 

[Ninja_sheep]

y xD I only c'n'ped. Is this illegal for submitted icons? xD

However I can modify them if you give me hints. I don't have photoshop but I know how to use gimp more or les :>

 

[HamsterBoo]

some hints if ur using photoshop. First make the main thing and its background 2 different layers (if you havent already), then maybe add some textures and stuff (make it look less bland) to each 1. I get that they are supposed to look like the real thing, but detail and textures are always nice.

 

[konerboy]

you could make it this way

 

[Ninja_sheep]

black background... hmmm, looks better. And more warcraft. rly looks better xD I'll test around a few things with the icons. Hope I get some good looking things :<

 

[ragingspeedhorn]

In their current state I see no reason as to why they should get approved. Any idiot could have made this in a few minutes of CnP'ing. In my opinion very significant changes needs to be made before these reaches approvable status.

 

[duyen]

In their current state I see no reason as to why they should get approved. Any idiot could have made this in a few minutes of CnP'ing. In my opinion very significant changes needs to be made before these reaches approvable status.

Does that lessen the usefulness?

 

[Ninja_sheep]

I don't know how it's done here but I think the icon should be judged by look and not by difficulty/time you spent on it.

However, main reason of my post: I'll go to holidays tomorrow for 1 week. So I can't make the icons better now :<

 

[duyen]

I don't know how it's done here but I think the icon should be judged by look and not by difficulty/time you spent on it.

However, main reason of my post: I'll go to holidays tomorrow for 1 week. So I can't make the icons better now :<

Agreed

 

[ragingspeedhorn]

I completely disagree. 100% CnP icons that doesn't even look that good shouldn't be approved and hopefully they won't be.

If someone wants those elements they should be able to do the same work in MSPaint in a matter of minutes. If they don't know how to do that then they probably shouldn't be toying with map making in the first place.

 

[Ninja_sheep]

100% CnP icons that doesn't even look that good shouldn't be approved and hopefully they won't be.

I agree with that. But I didn't say that. I said there's nothing bad about c'n'p icons but there's something bad on BAD c'n'p icons. However I don't say these should get approved if mine look crappy xD

 

[Hatebreeder]

I agree with that. But I didn't say that. I said there's nothing bad about c'n'p icons but there's something bad on BAD c'n'p icons. However I don't say these should get approved if mine look crappy xD

These arn't realy your Property. It's MTG's. They have Copy-Right on them, you know?
Anyways, if you manage to get the glow on the Icons, then I might even download them

 

[Trollvottel]

well id like the buttons if they werent for warcraft.... they fit 1% in the game (1% because of the border...) you had to change the whole interface to let them look good ingame IMO

 

[FhelZone]

Kiddy toy blocks? Looks like one to me XD

 

[konerboy]

Kiddy toy blocks? Looks like one to me XD

yeah make it more warcraft-ish try make it like i did

 

[T.s.e]

Gotta agree with the last poster here, it needs more shading and more... work done into them. No offense, but they look close to exactly as the ones from MTG.