Sig Battle 3! > 13lade619 vs Smith_S9

[13lade619]

ok, another sig battle is here.
I challenged everybody to a battle and guess who accepted,
the progenitor of sig battles here on TH, Smith_S9.

here are the sigs:

*I use knives69 in all my sigs.

now, it’s time to vote for who you think has the best sig

you can also post your comments on the renders. pros, cons, etc.

The winner will be repped by the other one and by whoever else wants to rep him for this.

:: The Thread :: The render I gave Smith_S9 :: The render Smith_S9 gave me ::

 

[Monovertex]

Suggestion: those rounded corners are already pixelated, so you could have saved it as GIF, to be viewed correctly in all browsers.

I won't vote, in fair-play purpose.

When does the poll ends?

 

[13lade619]

Suggestion: those rounded corners are already pixelated, so you could have saved it as GIF, to be viewed correctly in all browsers.

thanks for the suggestion. i'll update later and see if it looks better...

EDIT : saving it as gif is making it worse. the glow effect is disappearing and the quality is very low...

 

[Monovertex]

What glow? lol

And yeah, you are right, I suppose it's because you have too many fading colors and probably because the color pallete. Sometimes the GIFs look great.

Anyway, it doesn't really matters.

 

[Monovertex]

Btw, when does the poll ends? xP

Sorry for double-post, btw.

 

[Master]

>This poll will close on September 29th, 2007 at 05:30 AM

take a better look next time

 

[Pineapple]

I can't vote... I like them both evenly

 

[Monovertex]

>This poll will close on September 29th, 2007 at 05:30 AM

take a better look next time

Oh, my bad. At least I bumped the poll .

 

[Hero]

>This poll will close on September 29th, 2007 at 05:30 AM

take a better look next time

You finally back...

So...how was everything...oh right...this is off topic..

I like number 2 for some reason....

# 1 looks really dark..

and no I don't like # 2 cause of the girl ..or maybe I do

Voting # 2..

No offense Smith..

Just that I think you have done better >.<

 

[Demonwrath]

Okay...so who did what sig? O.O

Because #2 looks nice and all...however #1 has the erie look I always love.

 

[sqrage]

Fixed the poll options...Numbers instead of names.

I voted for #2, it looks nice and it has nice dept. First one looks flat.

Also, I don't like the text in either, but the one in the first one is barely visible.

 

[ArmedCitizen]

I like the first one better. The effects around the hand look just amazing. Like Hawk or whatever his name is, is just cutting through the lights. Sweetness.

Two was very well done, too, but I just didn't think the effects were as impressive. And the rounded edges look pretty bad.

 

[Squll2]

smith.. is.. losing.. =O

 

[Cheddar]

I voted for #1; it blends well and uses a wide variety of colors.

 

[SFilip]

Smith made the render blend in too well (again) to the point where it looks very low quality.
13lade619's is very nice, got my vote, but it has some parts of the render (mostly the hair) have visibly sharp edges.

 

[Halo_king116]

There are certain parts of #2 I dislike very much, but overall it still beats #1. I can't even really see the text, which is important.

Both are good, though #2 has my vote.

 

[Monovertex]

which is important.

I knew it's not . The text itself is not an effect to be so important. Seeing that some of the people don't like the text being too difficult to see, next time I won't put text at all .

Anyway, too bad for me, I know this not one of my bests .

 

[Halo_king116]

The text is important to me. Also making it looks good, is doubly important. Had you not put text I wouldn't of even though of coting for you.

Why? the signature is meant to be the owner's signature. It's theirs, not anyone else's. It's meant to be unique to them, and practically every signature I see has some text on it, to say whos it is. Without the person's name, or some indication it's unique to the Sig's owner, it's just an image, not a Sig.

To me, the text is extremely important. But that's just me.


Have a good one.

 

[ertaboy356b]

I liked them both, but I think I vote for Sig no. 2... I liked orange, especially the anime... But you better stick to your old avatar (The green one), because it look good too..

 

[13lade619]

BUMP!!

c'mon people, vote for who you think is better.