Signature Contest XIV

[Sil3nt]

#1
The glittery sparkly effects on the right always gets my attention.

 

[Narwy]

yea azn, sorry. Have to disqualify you. You can't reveal which one is yours before contest ends.

Can't get the idea of this that you cant reveal whos sih which one is.

haven't seen such system in any gfx forum or such



anyways, i wont vote any of these :/ though two of em look'd really nice, but i think it's not good idea that everyone makes sig from same render, i think theme would work better

 

[undeadorcjerk]

yea, i enjoy that concept too, but alas, i'm not the one who set down the rules the first time around.

 

[Nigerianrulz]

yea, i enjoy that concept too, but alas, i'm not the one who set down the rules the first time around.

im pretty sure itz whitesock who setted the rules

i think that rule should be taken off soon because the gfx level is no longer a huge gap so..

 

[Pineapple]

im pretty sure itz whitesock who setted the rules

i think that rule should be taken off soon because the gfx level is no longer a huge gap so..

heh, actually it was me And its not just that, its so people don't say 'well, I will vote whitesock to get in good with him.'

For example, I remember a bit back someone said "oh sorry ____! If I had known that was yours I would have voted for it!"

We all have biases in voting, no name removes them.

I know I would never intentionally vote for purge.*

*You know I love ya <3​

Ah, looking back, we used to give good time for these contest, 2 weeks or more to make, a week to vote, evens out to about 1 a month. Now it all seems so rushed.

 

[Prometheus]

I would vote for 1 or 4 personally, compared to them, mine sucks.

 

[PurgeandFire]

For example, I remember a bit back someone said "oh sorry ____! If I had known that was yours I would have voted for it!"

I think Undead said that to me in one of the contests... But yeah, he said afterwards *Now I know why the names are hidden*

I know I would never intentionally vote for purge.*

D:

*You know I love ya <3​

:-D

 

[undeadorcjerk]

>>


<<


maybe....

 

[MarkXIV]

I'm for 5. Here's why:

1: Technical - 6 out of 10, artistic - 8 out of 10, total 14. Best composition.
2: Technical - 4 out of 10, artistic - 4 out of 10, total 8.
3:
4: Technical - 4 out of 10, artistic - 3 out of 10, total 7.
5: Technical - 8 out of 10, artistic - 7 out of 10, total 15. Best effects.
6: Technical - 4 out of 10, artistic - 3 out of 10, total 7.
7: Technical - 5 out of 10, artistic - 4 out of 10, total 9.

BTW, guys, don't you think all sigs better be of the same size and proportions?

 

[Prometheus]

No, it allows better variety.
I'm suprised at my sig's score up there.
I also disagree with your rating of #4.

 

[MarkXIV]

No, it allows better variety.
I'm suprised at my sig's score up there.
I also disagree with your rating of #4.

#4 is too monotone for me. Pale, weak and empty. #1 and #5 are way stronger, mostly due to contrast and colors.

As for variety, why the same render then? I think additional restriction will make the contest a little more difficult i.e. interesting.

 

[duyen]

I find it pitiful that someone would vote for him/herself.

 

[Exide]

>I find it pitiful that someone would vote for him/herself.
Well SOMEONE has to vote for me!

 

[Prometheus]

>I find it pitiful that someone would vote for him/herself.
Well SOMEONE has to vote for me!

Which would make it seem like you're entry #2.

 

[duyen]

Anybody want to guess which ones mine?

Of course I won't tell if your right (as that's against the rule that was never made a rule), but I just want to see if people can guess

 

[Pineapple]

Anybody want to guess which ones mine?

Of course I won't tell if your right (as that's against the rule that was never made a rule), but I just want to see if people can guess

you are not suppose to reveal yours, so yea it is

Also, I think we claimed not to guess whos is whos, becuase it can cause confusion - people would be like, oh so that was ______ . Assuming that it was fact not a guess.

Not too big of a problem, but meh. Ask then to guess after its over

 

[Whitesock]

I find it pitiful that someone would vote for him/herself.

Mine isn't number 4 if anyone was wondering.

In fact, I don't believe I submitted one.

 

[undeadorcjerk]

nope, no sig from whitesock.

 

[Hero]

I like number 4 it looks unique.

The color may be pink but its a nulled tone of pink..not a hot pink..

So 4 got my vote.

 

[w/e]

Oh. My. God. :banghead:

People are supposed to vote for whichever signature they like best. They should NOT be swayed by their friend's votes or vote for themselves to try and make themselves regain at least a little of their dignity. People should vote for the best sig.

I believe that voting for yourself is acceptable only when you truly believe that your entry is the best. Still, I usually don't vote. It's more of a courtesy thing.