Signature Contest XVII Voting

[undeadorcjerk]

You all know the drill. Vote for the one that you think is the best.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.
--Disqualified--​

Good luck to all the contestants. Please pm me if it appears to be a problem. I will fix it asap.

 

[Pineapple]

2 is the best. But its too big. doesn't qualify as a sig. no one would put that in a sig. :\ Its a LP. thus i wont vote for it.

And 3 looks terrible! :thdown:

 

[Whitesock]

#1 does look quite nice.

 

[PurgeandFire]

Though #2 is big, I think it looks best. Gmv

 

[ReVolver]

I think we should disqualify #2... it's a LP not a sig. :thdown:

 

[sqrage]

I think we should disqualify #2... it's a LP not a sig. :thdown:

Seconded.

I like number one very much. :]

 

[duyen]

Mine isn't there?!??!?

Now I've lost as people didn't have a chance to vote for me and if you add mine people will know it's mine.

 

[PurgeandFire]

I think we should disqualify #2... it's a LP not a sig. :thdown:

It can't be disqualified because it follows all the rules. Undead said the max dimensions were 500x300, didn't he?

»The largest width size is 500
»The largest hight size is 300.

 

[gameman]

aparrently insane did not make one or he failed at making one

 

[undeadorcjerk]

2 is the best. But its too big. doesn't qualify as a sig. no one would put that in a sig. :\ Its a LP. thus i wont vote for it.

Not true. I have seen bigger on signature sites.

I would vote for that one because it is undoubtedly the best. Size doesn't matter as long as it fits the rules.

Sorry Anman. If you wouldn't have posted, I coulda added yours and you would have had a fair chance.

 

[ArmedCitizen]

I'd say it is too small to be a large piece. A little bigger than the average signature but shouldn't the best ones break away from the average?

Though number one has some cool stuff going on it seems a little too busy. I voted for the second.

 

[duyen]

Not true. I have seen bigger on signature sites.

I would vote for that one because it is undoubtedly the best. Size doesn't matter as long as it fits the rules.

Sorry Anman. If you wouldn't have posted, I coulda added yours and you would have had a fair chance.

Fuck this?

So I don't have a chance to enter because of YOUR mistake?

 

[undeadorcjerk]

No. You don't have a chance NOW because you decided to post in this thread saying I forgot yours. If you wouldn't have posted, I could have entered you in to the contest and the mistake would have been gone.

It is now equally your fault as it is mine.

 

[Atreyu]

Love #2. =) It isn't very plain. I can see it clearly. I think.

Off-topic
--- Where can I request a signature? ---

 

[w/e]

Even though 2 is still more of a LB, it still GMV. The other ones are actually pretty good, too, but I think 2 has really good lighting and composition.

 

[Pineapple]

The main reason 2 is 'so good' is becuase it is so big, allows it to be clearer then normal.

 

[undeadorcjerk]

The main reason 2 is 'so good' is becuase it is so big, allows it to be clearer then normal.

That is why everyone should have taken advantage of the size limits. The person who did that was very smart.

 

[duyen]

No. You don't have a chance NOW because you decided to post in this thread saying I forgot yours. If you wouldn't have posted, I could have entered you in to the contest and the mistake would have been gone.

It is now equally your fault as it is mine.

Where in the rules did it say I can't post that you forgot mine, the first one submitted?

I'm really pissed off.:banghead::banghead::banghead::banghead:

 

[w/e]

No. You don't have a chance NOW because you decided to post in this thread saying I forgot yours. If you wouldn't have posted, I could have entered you in to the contest and the mistake would have been gone.

It is now equally your fault as it is mine.

Even so, votes would have been placed without the voters seeing all of the entries, thus tilting the scale against Anman because he was losing potential votes.
Also, as for # 2 being too big....the max dimensions were placed and that image is withing the rules. Stop complaining.

 

[undeadorcjerk]

Where in the rules did it say I can't post that you forgot mine, the first one submitted?

No the rule is not to reveal which one is yours. By posting that I forgot yours means that everyone will know that the added one is yours. Thus you break the first rule by posting.


And regarding your lovely -rep. How will you suffer by my mistake?