End of Year Contest - Submissions

[Romek]

> EDIT: Someone please tell me what is wrong with Spoilers?
There's nothing 'wrong' with them.

 

[SerraAvenger]

> EDIT: Someone please tell me what is wrong with Spoilers?
There's nothing 'wrong' with them.

They just don't work.

 

[AceHart]

Final poll results (count, who - what, who voted):

10 votes
Brutal - Summon Treant
D.V.D Daskunk Dragon_Lance furby777 Immolation Larcenist Razed SerraAvenger Slapshot136 UndeadDragon

XeNiM666 - Unleash Xaphros
ccsdude Dragon_Lance DrEvil I_RULE_YOU MasterRofl Rhymer Romek SerraAvenger Slapshot136 YaY_simulato


6 votes
Smith_S9 - Lightning Fiend
Gwypaas kc102 kirbyman1 Romek UndeadDragon WolfieNoCT


5 votes
Draphoelix - Summon Water Elemental
Drunken_God I_RULE_YOU Kelvin87 kirbyman1 XeNiM666

Gwypaas - Abstract Rift
Akolyt0r D.V.D Kelvin87 minikrampan ThelderHong

Infinitegde - Summon Fire Lord
cOdFiShY DrEvil Immolation ThelderHong XeNiM666

Minikrampan - Summon Spell
Dragon_Lance GeertPingen rDs_RaVeN Romek Slapshot136


4 votes
GhostWind - Infernal in a box
BRUTAL D.V.D kc102 WolfieNoCT

Kelvin87 - Summon Felwood Cocoon
bryanEX1993 Kelvin87 rDs_RaVeN ThelderHong

Kirbyman1 - Summon Spirit
Gwypaas I_RULE_YOU lolapan Smith_S9

vypur - Summon Ice Panda
DrEvil Drunken_God Larcenist Smith_S9


3 votes
Dragon_Lance - Lightning Minion
kc102 rDs_RaVeN WolfieNoCT


1 vote
emootootoo - Summon Morph Elemental
Larcenist

Galdiuz - Summon Demon
Smith_S9

Nherwyziant - Seeking Vengeance
Immolation


No votes for the others, sorry...




As such, the following entries will be considered in great detail by the judges:
Brutal - Summon Treant
XeNiM666 - Unleash Xaphros
Smith_S9 - Lightning Fiend
Draphoelix - Summon Water Elemental
Gwypaas - Abstract Rift
Infinitegde - Summon Fire Lord
Minikrampan - Summon Spell


Stay tuned.

Hulk3, where art thou?

 

[emjlr3]

i pm'd thee o flea infested one...

 

[Monovertex]

Any chances for us to see grades?...

 

[emjlr3]

when they are grade you will see them - why would we hold back?

 

[Monovertex]

Ok, I reiterate: any chances for you guys to get the grades done?

That's what I meant in the first place, not that you wouldn't show them to us.

 

[emjlr3]

they'll get done when we have an opportunity (and the desire) to sit down and grade them

as of now - I havn't even downloaded the zip file

 

[Kelvin87]

May I comment something on the grading system? I think the number of voting too less and cannot be guided majority on it. The percentage portion of the voting should be in minor portion (typically 15%), and majority should be judged on both of you as judges on these maps. Although this is just a simple or small competition, it should also be professional and fair enough to all submissions.

The theme not only applicable on this competition only, but the method of using (flashy summoning spell) in any summoning maps or spells should be useful, effective and can let people who visited the helper - world editor get a very good reference and can be learned easily from it as well.

 

[emjlr3]

voting was simply a means to reduce the headache for Ace and I - and in no way is reflected in the final judging

 

[emjlr3]

I got my grades to Ace, expect something soon

 

[AceHart]

                                    Flashy  Code    Theme  General  Total
Summon Treant - Brutal               17 13   8 7     5  5   5  3,5    63,5
Unleash Xaphos - XeNiM666            14 18   7 8     5  5   3  3,5    63,5
Abstract Rift - Gwypass              14 18   6 7,5   5  5   4  3,5    63
Summon Firelord - Infinitedge        14 19   5 7,5   5  5   3  3      61,5
Summon Water Elemental - Draphoelix  12 12   5 7,5   5  5   4  3      53,5
Lightning Fiend - Smith_09           12 11   5 5     5  5   3  2,5    48,5
Feast Rain - Minikrampan             10 10   5 5     5  5   5  2,5    47,5

Values given in the order "AceHart Hulk3", except for the total.


Total flashy points given: 194 of 280 possible, i.e. 69% only.
Still better than coding which only got 63% of all possible points...



Congratulations to the winners and the nearly winners.



In case you feel like reading some random rants:

 

[BRUTAL]

finally results ;o

but in the SummoningContest_grading.txt file, i noticed the marks for my spell and a few others are different then what ace's post says, but some are the same, any reason for that?

but congrats to the other winners

 

[BlackRose]

You damn confused me, who's the winner?

Summon Treant - Brutal 17 13 8 7 5 5 5 3,5 63,5
Unleash Xaphos - XeNiM666 14 18 7 8 5 5 3 3,5 63,5

?

 

[AceHart]

Sorry about that.
The actual idea was to post the final all-in-one text...

 

[emjlr3]

congrats - looks like there is a tie for first, thus two first place finishers and a third

bout damn time Ace!

hadn't you said something along the lines of rewards? what shall they be? and what ever happened to the medal vb system?

 

[BRUTAL]

i hope my spell summoning a treant didnt affect my grade

hadn't you said something along the lines of rewards?

isnt it just rep? : s