I dunno. For an extremely over-the-top review, I've found that I actually agree with a surprising amount of it.
I'm also inclined to argue that that it's actually at the start that it's the best; the AotC and RotS reviews are the ones that degenerate into a whole lot of moderately entertaining but conceptually bland nitpicking. The TPM review is actually reasonably focused, and it describes with good examples and good use of generalization various systemic problems with the entire prequel series, so much so that I would go as far as to say that the other two reviews might be unnecessary.
I think #3 has about half the amount of new content that the previous two reviews had. It's as if Plinkett has ran out of steam at that point. Or probably because Lucas did manage to write something that resembles a plot for the third part.
But the second review still talks about new things. Like the love story and the relationship between Anakin and Obi Wan.
I think we need to add something to the bottom of the front page that shows the Headline News forum that has a link to go to the News Forum Index so people can see there is more news. Do you guys see what I am saying, lets say you read all the articles on the front page and you get to the end and it just ends, no kind of link for MOAR!
Finally finding about some of the bots that are flooding the users online - bytespider apparently is a huge offender here - ignores robots.txt and comes in from a ton of different IPs
Ghan has said he has fixed this. Monovertex please confirm this fix. This was only a problem with people that had signatures in the upper levels like not the special members but the respected members.