Which Idea Sounds Better?

[Frosthowl]

Hello, im trying to make a new 6 on 6 aos that features the ability to use seige equipment to attack the enemy sides keep as well as mixing in the traditional hack, slash, and spell theme that is in almost any aos. It also requires the players to kill a large boss hero that has fully scripted abilities and a ai. I cant decide what story to go along with. Please vote.

-A-
The lich king arthas is facing off against the humans who desire to bring about justice after he slayed their king. The bosses would be arthas and the one human guy from WOTLK. This video that WoW made sums up the story: http://www.worldofwarcraft.com/wrath/wrathgate.xml. Kind of a holy (human) verses undead theme here. The people are fighting to avenge the late king.

-B-
This idea is somewhat more unique. It has the lich king arthas facing against Sylvanus, who wants to settle the score for turning her into an undead. The units would by mostly undead vs undead with some horde mixed in on sylvanus's side.

Please vote which sounds more interesting.

 

[Azlier]

Sylvanas vs. Arthas would be a nice change. Plain old humans vs undead has been done so many times...

 

[CaptDeath]

so many times the ideas undead o.0

 

[Azlier]

Well, what else could you have? Orcs vs. Humans? Done that. Night Elves vs. Undead? Dota. Undead vs. Orcs? Actually, never seen that one done.

 

[CaptDeath]

or night elves vs humans?

 

[Curo]

I'd do Naga vs Night Elves, since they have similar heritage, so you could easily make a story around that. Also it would make for nice terrain since half the map would have watery areas, and the other half would be forested.

 

[Frosthowl]

I had that idea, but I am unable to do that with this map because of the whole seiging a castle idea...elves nor naga are known for building large fortifications...plus im into the icy theme right now.

 

[Curo]

If it's an icy theme you are going for, I'd definitely do Dwarves then. They are known for fortifications too. This would be going back to RoC human campaign when the Dwarves are stranded in Northrend. Perhaps they could be against a race of Nerubians, or otherwise Undead.

 

[CaptDeath]

hey frost im making some [frosty] command buttons you know the Move stop hold i can pm you a preview if you want

 

[Kitt]

I actually like the second option. It's interesting, and the tension feels more real then some more forced ideas. Also, I really like that it completely forgoes the very typical "light vs dark" feel.

Mew.

 

[Frosthowl]

hey frost im making some [frosty] command buttons you know the Move stop hold i can pm you a preview if you want

Sure, I would love to see what they look like. Might even use them.

 

[wraithseeker]

Arthas vs sylvanas but arthas would be buffed more,