That should be pretty informative and still won't encourage arguements on every little point. I personally think it is enough information, but, of course, any judge could also give a short explanation on why he thinks the submission deserved the grade he gave it.
Here is my submission. I would check it more but... I don't wanna' say I don't care about this anymore but I've been really busy these days so I just want to get this over with and checking and stuff. Good luck to everyone else! Hope you like my story!
Well, you can close it. I've lost interest in judging a short story contest, and I'm sure most people have lost interest in participating. If there's another short story contest make sure to keep me off the judging list.
Unfortunately, this contest is going to be discontinued - both due to lack of judges and lack of member interest. Sorry guys, but there was one submission and one judge - that doesn't make for much of a contest.