Some more sigs...Opinions?

[hobo218]

Here's a Halo sig I made.
I can't decide which version I like better. If anyone really wants this one I can still find the layered version.

Opinions and/or Feedback?

[EDIT]
Here's a RvB sig I made a while back, thought I'd share it. Not looking for any feedback because I just made it for fun.

[EDIT]
-Most Current Version-

 

[sqrage]

for the first two put 2 px border

 

[hobo218]

 

[sqrage]

ok it's better now, i like
http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y284/hobo_218/halo2.png
that one more

 

[Halo_king116]

The border looks good. I like just about everything about it, but there is one thing I don't know thatdoesn't make it perfect.

For the one with the lines or w.e they are, perhaps not put them over the render area, or something like that. Just a suggestion.

Just wait until Orc_Tamer and w/e come here and bash it


8/10

 

[w/e]

The text is misplaced on all three. I like the halo backgorund. The one with the pattern is better but, the pattern should be behind the render. I don't like the horizontal lines that run across it. The render also seems like it came in a better quality. The caboose one has to much text. I think. And you should make hobo218 the central object. Otherwise they're good.
Halo: 7/10.
Caboose: 6.5/10
Bashing complete.

 

[sqrage]

The text is misplaced on all three. I like the halo backgorund. The one with the pattern is better but, the pattern should be behind the render. I don't like the horizontal lines that run across it. The render also seems like it came in a better quality. The caboose one has to much text. I think. And you should make hobo218 the central object. Otherwise they're good.
Halo: 7/10.
Caboose: 6.5/10
Bashing complete.

just because it's not cliche doesn't mean the text is misplaced

 

[w/e]

Sorry, what I meant was I think it would look better if it was elsewhere.

 

[Rinpun]

I like the text on the Caboose sig (it's a good quote ). However, you could try flushing it to the left below "Caboose".

 

[hobo218]

How's that?

And w/e, I wasn't askin for any feedback on the Caboose one, and it's a quote from RvB...
Wasn't intended for a sig...

Though I do see what you're saying Rinpun. Unfortunatly I don't think I have the xcf for that anymore....lol

 

[w/e]

Sorry. This one loogs much much better. The render and BG are in perfect sync in terms of color and now the font is on top. But I think the font needs to be clearer and the sig shorter. Than it'll be great.

 

[Halo_king116]

The text... Does it say Kobo28?

Lmao Other than that I think it looks good. But who am I to tell?

 

[hobo218]

Nah, hobo218, but I couldn't find any other font's that looked really good. The ones that I like I use/other people use to much..

Thanks for the feedback guys.

 

[w/e]

I have a crapload of fonts. Want me to upload?

 

[Whitesock]

I think their both good, but the text of the quote needs to be flush with the left and smaller.

 

[hobo218]

Yeah if you don't mind.
Thanks.

[EDIT]
New Version-Shorter and with clearer font