Terraining Contest, Reward being decided.

[Jindo]

Finally a cave!

we havent had many caves, not sure if we've had any at all lol .

well that looks very good, i can see that caves with lava are your style man, you also have a good chance of winning .

Ill add you and UnknowVector's links now while i have time .

(this is why i kept the contest open til the deadline, people in at the last minute lol!)

~Jindo

 

[ShadowSnipe4]

I just scanned through the thread and didnt see anything about multiple entries. Can we submit more than once different terrain?

 

[Luciann]

Thnx, alot of the other art looks very nice as well! Looks like a good competition.

Question though, has there been a decision on the reward yet? or ideas?
just curious lol

 

[Jindo]

@ShadowSnip4: look carefully, we said you can take as many screenies as you can aslong as they're screenshots of the same map.

@Luciann: we've been talking ALOT, we've been thinking of maybe an avatar, we cant do a signature because of complicated reasons. And i dont think the winner would get rep if we asked for that as a reward.

For now an avatar, when i find a better reward, well use that.

~Jindo

 

[Luciann]

Just had a question about something I saw that was different in my map than the others, and was wondering if it was ok.

If you notice in my screen shots I made the Roc fly around as if it was an actual scene and not a screenshot of an editor pic, and I'm not sure if that goes against the rules? I also don't see any reason it should, just covering to check and make sure its ok.

We dont have to have our units in the same place in every screenshow do we? I'm purely talking about units, moving doodads around randomly might be different but , well idk.... just curious.


Just tryed to make it more cinematic and I wanted to ask before anyone might point it out and might say its a problem.

 

[AgentPaper]

Heres my map, no screen shots (no time lol) but it will cycle through a few cams that i think capture it best.

 

[Jindo]

that looks nice, illadd your name when i get time.

Submit maps in TODAY!

No more maps will be accepted tomorrow, today is your last chance, tomorrow the judging begins!

~Jindo

 

[DM Cross]

Bump

Are we supposed to judge over MSN or something, Jindo, or should I just Post/PM my voting to you and you'll average it out?

 

[Jindo]

hmm.. to be honest, i think PM would be alot quicker .

alexander and kc102, send me your results over MSN, remember to use the links on the first page to get to their work faster.

~Jindo

 

[DM Cross]

How are we doing the voting?

What are the categories?
What is the scale?

Should we average the category scores to get a general score and just give you that?

Questions, questions

 

[Myzteryz]

msn, msn, and pm, pm
don't discuss it hear, walls have ears.. or in that case maps have eyes...

 

[Jindo]

I sent judges a PM, they understand (when they read it ).

~Jindo

 

[Husky]

You guys still deciding on a winner? Oh and if you can be bothered can you list people in like 1st-10th (or whatever) or just 1st, 2nd, 3rd?
Thanks,
-Husky

 

[Duwenbasden]

msn, msn, and pm, pm
don't discuss it hear, walls have ears.. or in that case maps have eyes...

I swear they don't have Witch Doctors or Sentry Packs in those parts! I swear!

 

[DM Cross]

You guys still deciding on a winner? Oh and if you can be bothered can you list people in like 1st-10th (or whatever) or just 1st, 2nd, 3rd?
Thanks,
-Husky

I just sent Jindo my scores a while before. I forgot who the other judge is, but you're probably just going to be waiting on him now

Good luck to everyone, and good work Was hard to judge, my friends, hard to judge.

 

[-----]

Can you post your individual ratings now, or must you wait for all the results and collate them...?

 

[DM Cross]

Personally, I refuse to post my ratings.

And I do not give permission for them to be publically posted.

Thus, you will only get the final vote for each person, if Jindo gives even that.

Why do I not give/allow my ratings to be posted? (I know I'll be asked this)

Simple. I don't need this person or that person to complain that they don't think I voted fairly because they like the terrain, or they like the person who made it, or the person who made it is the one complaining. Why don't I want this?

1) It's annoying.
2) I couldn't care less.
3) I'm the judge, not you!
4) It's annoying.

So, in short, after all that babble, no you shall not have my ratings

 

[hobo218]

might as well bump

 

[Husky]

Come on Jindo, we wanna know whos won it ...
-Husky

 

[Jindo]

I may as well, ive had no reply from kc102 about the results.

Ill post the results, they include the 3 categories plus the totals.

Ill be doing 1st 2nd and 3rd but only 1st place will get a reward (when we've decided ).

The highest possible score in a category is 20, the highest possible total is 60.

---

RESULTS:

Husky_003
Mapping - 18
Use of Scenery - 19
Use of Space - 18
Total = 55/60

Krakka
Mapping - 17
Use of Scenery - 15
Use of Space - 16
Total = 48/60

Killfest2
Mapping - 18
Use of Scenery - 16
Use of Space - 16
Total = 50/60

Tom Green
Mapping - 19
Use of Scenery - 17
Use of Space - 19
Total = 55/60

Sheep Quest
Mapping - 16
Use of Scenery - 16
Use of Space - 17
Total = 49/60

Sqrage
Mapping - 17
Use of Scenery - 18
Use of Space - 16
Total = 51/60

Lg
Mapping - 17
Use of Scenery - 16
Use of Space - 17
Total = 50/60

BrokenX
Mapping - 17
Use of Scenery - 19
Use of Space - 19
Total = 55/60

ShadowSnip4
Mapping - 16
Use of Scenery - 16
Use of Space - 17
Total = 49/60

Duwenbasden
Mapping - 18
Use of Scenery - 19
Use of Space - 17
Total = 54/60

Luccian
Mapping - 20
Use of Scenery - 19
Use of Space - 18
Total = 57/60

AgentPaper
Mapping - 17
Use of Scenery - 18
Use of space - 15
Total = 50/60

UnkowVector
Mapping - 16
Use of Scenery - 14
Use of Space - 14
Total = 44/60

Hobo218
Mapping - 16
Use of Scenery - 16
Use of Space - 16
Total = 48/60

Rinpun
Mapping - 16
Use of Scenery - 17
Use of Space - 18
Total = 51/60

---

1st place: Luciann - 57/60
2nd place: BrokenX, husky_003, Tom_Green - 55/60
3rd place: Duwenbasden - 54/60

Congratulations to those 3 and well done to everyone who participated .

~Jindo