Signature Tournament - Round 3: Voting

[Naminator]

Round 3 Voting:
Theme: Muddy Waters
Please vote for the best sig between the two fighting user. Try to keep the voting legal.

User's Signatures:

====================================================================
1º Battle:

Uberplayer: -> Desqualify

Narwain:

====================================================================
2º Battle:

Purgeandfire:

w/e:

====================================================================

Start Voting!

 

[Pineapple]

w/e was much nicer. I dont like the rainbow-ey thing.

Also, all these people not handing in sigs is terrible. Ruins the whole point of this.

(Not picking on you Uberplayer, others have done it aswell)

 

[Whitesock]

Purge you should have put the bottom right color thing behind the guy to make it look less flat.

 

[w/e]

Omg, Narwy's sig ownz. As usual...

 

[Insane!]

Sorry purge :^(

 

[undeadorcjerk]

>Omg, Narwy's sig ownz. As usual...

And thats why I picked him to be the winner of the tournament.


>Sorry purge :^(

ditto

 

[Exide]

I voted for Purge, because I couldn't see what had been done to w/e's sig. It sort of looks like any picture, with some text saying blues. It would be much easier to know if I saw the original.
I like the idea of Purge's sig, but I think it misses something. The rainbow thing looks very out of place, and 'color' is written as if it was a gameboy color commercial I also like how the picture "rocks". (I guess it's just the guy on the picture that rocks, but the whole signature seems to rock, imo. Which is really neat! )

 

[PurgeandFire]

The original of mine looks a little different. I suppose w/e's is too.

http://www.mediastorehouse.com/image/Muddy-Waters-American-Blues-singer_179858.jpg

Hehe

But for most, quality > quantity. That's why I try to auto assume the quantity when I critique.

My sig is a little random.

W/e's sig looks slightly overexposed.

Narwy's effects are amazing but the teal doesn't fit.

HAHAHAA! I seriously actually dig deep to find some critique. :\

Great job and best of luck guys! I'm going to get pwned! At least I reserve 3rd place

 

[w/e]

Unfourtunately, I lost my original picture. But it was very different. Yes, I suppose I kind of overdid the exposure.

All in all, it is a great tournament. It would have been greater if Narwain had actually participated against others.
Sorry narwain, but you can be intimidating.

And purge, I think you have a great sig, but I think that the rainbow kind of ruined it for me because it contrasts too much with the old black and white theme of the photo. I think that if you had added more effects around the rainbow, such as some particles or external lighting, it would have easily pwned mine.

 

[undeadorcjerk]

I think the teal in Narwain's is awesome. And w/e has a point. The rainbow... totally screws it up.

 

[Nigerianrulz]

the rainbow idea was good but if u made it thinner it would look really nice

now about narwys somehow im just not feeling the sig, the effect is good but i just couldnt really feel the blues xD

anywayz gl u guys

 

[Exide]

See. Purge's original doesn't "rock", yet the signature does!
Imho, Purge's is the better one.

 

[Narwy]

w/e got my vote

purge's semicoloured one doesnt work :/

anyway, what's a teal? im not so good in english ^^ sry

 

[Nigerianrulz]

w/e got my vote

purge's semicoloured one doesnt work :/

anyway, what's a teal? im not so good in english ^^ sry

teal is main colour you used

in another word.. lighter than light blue?

 

[Exide]

Teal is Player 3's color in Warcraft. A mix between blue and green.
For more information, see google.com

Speaking of Narwain's sig, I think the right side of the guy's head looks a bit weird.. well both sides those, but the right side looks more weird.

 

[Uberplayer]

>Also, all these people not handing in sigs is terrible.
I know. I was against this when people began to do so. But I had pretty good reason for it.. It wouldn't have made any difference to voting, because it's impossible for me to get a single vote if I am against Narwain (only Narwain and I would vote me). We saw it in our sig battle. And then another reason is that I want to focus more on the WelpZones Cinematic Contest, because there I can actually do something..

 

[Whitesock]

I know. I was against this when people began to do so. But I had pretty good reason for it.. It wouldn't have made any difference to voting, because it's impossible for me to get a single vote if I am against Narwain (only Narwain and I would vote me). We saw it in our sig battle. And then another reason is that I want to focus more on the WelpZones Cinematic Contest, because there I can actually do something..

Nevertheless, it's still polite to submit an entry reguardless if you think you can win or not.

 

[monoVertex]

Sorry Purge, but the rainbow screwed it up :'(...

 

[PurgeandFire]

Wah D:

Get some more votes people!

Also, do I get an icon, or is it only for first?

 

[w/e]

Yeah, I was wondering about that as well...

w00t, I can't wait to get owned next round!