Signature Contest XVIII Voting

[Sil3nt]

Voting ends in 5 days
Do not vote if you have entered
When voting, please explain why
Good luck to all entrants!

In no order

1

2

3

4

​

 

[Atreyu]

I vote for Signature #3 because of the effects. Since this was a Self-made contest where you can't go and get a picture. #3's the best entry.

 

[duyen]

1

The reason I voted for 1 is because it was the only one that had the quality, all the others were jpg and pixelated.

I didn't really "like" any of them though.

 

[Newbwc3]

Three. Never really got started on my sig for this like I said I would. To busy. Maybe next time.

 

[Exide]

1

The reason I voted for 1 is because it was the only one that had the quality, all the others were jpg and pixelated.

I didn't really "like" any of them though.

Um, what does it matter if they are .jpg or not?

 

[duyen]

Um, what does it matter if they are .jpg or not?

jpg = fail to society

The quality and file size.

 

[Exide]

jpg = fail to society

The quality and file size.

But you can't tell the difference by just looking at a picture..

 

[duyen]

Oh I can all right.

I could tell right away that the only one that was png was #1 and I assumed 3 and 4 were jpgs. (I didn't know if they were gif or bmp until I looked at file extension)

I could not tell if #2 was jpg or png.

If you examine each one closely you will see.

 

[Exide]

If I wasn't in the contest, I'd vote for number 1, because it's simply the best! =)

 

[Nigerianrulz]

omgz i missed out didnt make it home on time...

voted for 1.

simlpe but beautiful

 

[BANANAMAN]

3

 

[Prometheus]

Three

 

[emjlr3]

Hulk Smash!

 

[PurgeandFire]

Hulk Smash!

Lol.

Number 3 because of the focal strength, and nice use of gradient maps. (It looks like they are used... at least )

EDIT: 1 also looks pretty sweet! The only thing I thought it could use was more buildings and possibly more to it such as cell shading, different colored buildings. But that would be a little overboard perhaps.

 

[Sil3nt]

1
Everything is smooth and straight with nice colors to fit in.
3 also looked nice but the depth is a bit wierd and the c4d flow is also not clear in some areas. Also a bit too sharp imo.

 

[undeadorcjerk]

I don't think three should be included. If you didn't know that the theme was city, you wouldn't be able to tell that the stock in the background is part of a city. I think it focuses on Hulk more then the city.

Just my opinion.



Also, it has the maker's name in the image url. Maybe... I can't tell if he made that or the maker put someone else's name in it.

 

[Darthfett]

I don't think three should be included. If you didn't know that the theme was city, you wouldn't be able to tell that the stock in the background is part of a city. I think it focuses on Hulk more then the city.

QFT That's the reason I didn't vote for it.

 

[Prometheus]

Also, it has the maker's name in the image url. Maybe... I can't tell if he made that or the maker put someone else's name in it.

You thinking emjlr3?
Also, #3 fits the requirements fine.

 

[Sil3nt]

Well I didn't specify it has to be focussed directly on a city. It could've been a stock with some girl walking down the city or maybe a car thats driving through the city as long as it is related to "city" in some way. It's only in when there is no relevance at all that it will be removed. But other than that if you don't think its related enought then just don't vote for it.

And no emjlr3 didn't enter, the person just named it that, probably because emjlr3 has a hulk avatar and was brainwashed.

 

[undeadorcjerk]

oh.... emjlr3 is an evil brainwashing cultest...